Motorbuys | Local Jobs | Homes | Rental Property | Coupons | Garage Sales| Classifieds | Worship | ShopNow
May 12, 2008, 2:40 am
Send your favorite photo to  snapshots at Savage Pacer
Welcome to the new Savagepacer.com, the home page of the Savage Pacer newspaper. Let us know what you think of the changes to the site.
Got a news tip? Email us, or call us at (952) 440-1234

User login

Email Edition
Type in your email address and click "Subscribe" to receive our E-mail Edition in your inbox.




Add our RSS feed to your favorite service.

Add to Google Reader or Homepage

Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Add to My AOL

Get Firefox

Expelled



No votes yet

I saw the movie "Expelled" last night. Ben Stein and the others making the movie did a masterful job of shedding light on the fact that when it comes to science education in the USA, all speech is not created (or treated) equal.

The theory of evolution is now taught as fact across the land in spite of glaring holes in the theory that very smart, well educated scientists have exposed. However, if a scientist or professor dares to suggest that intelligent design should at least be part of the discussion in classrooms, the movie shows that move to be deadly to one's career.

Multiple professors in the movie lost tenure or even their jobs because they simply mentioned intelligent design in a paper or in a classroom. What happened to freedom of speech?

At a local level, it makes me wonder what would happen to a science teacher at Prior Lake High School if they mentioned intelligent design. Maybe I'll ask someone on the school board. I hope the answer is not "they would lose their job".

The movie also sheds light on the connection between Darwin and eugenics. Eugenics was very popular and advocated by people like Adolph Hitler and Margaret Sanger. We all know what Hitler did. Sanger was the founder of Planned Parenthood which is best known now for its abortion clinics and intense advocacy for abortion on demand. Eugenics basically is all about getting rid of the undesirables. For Hitler, undesirables included Jews, gays, blacks, etc. For Sanger, undesirables included the mentally retarded, the unborn, etc. Did you know that 50,000 Americans were sterilized against their will back in the early part of the last century? Why? Because they were not deemed fit to procreate and reproduce. Incredible.

Whatever side of the debate you are on, I encourage you to see this movie. It is very thought-provoking.


Freedom of speech is...

Back to page top

Freedom of speech is different for teachers in a public classroom, Savage Guy.

The First Ammendment contains the idea that the government has no authority to restrict expression because of its message, idea, subject matter or content.

That said, the Supreme Court has recognized the right to freedom of speech to teachers and has acknowledged that public schools have significant educational interests that must be balanced against those rights.

Therefore, a teacher's right to freedom of speech is governed by the broad authority that the legislature and courts have granted school boards to determine the curriculum and control teachers' freedom of speech iin the classroom.

I think that's your answer, Savage Guy.

There was a federal court case, Williams vs. Vidmar (Cupertino Union School District) where the federal court dismissed three of four claims brought on by a teacher who alledged the district censored his speech because he was a Christian.

The Court dismissed the violation of the First Ammendment charges, finding that "teachers do not have a constitutional right to determine what curriculum will be taught in the classroom."

The Court found that the teacher had no right to express religion in the classroom, because there is a "well-defined difference" existing between a teacher who is free to be a Christian and expressing faith in the classroom.

Now I understand that this is slightly different scenario, but I think it would still apply.

I think the question of firing would be whether or not the teachers continued after being warned or told it was inappropriate.

Students are often sent home for wearing shirts deemed innapropriate by dress code. Remember the kid in Alaska?

Even some students in Shakopee were sent home for wearing shirts the principal found innapropriate. Here's the story www.shakopeenews.com/news/general_news/students_sent_home_over_shirts-74....

I'll have to check this movie out, it sounds interesting.


Submitted by shawn hogendorf on April 25, 2008 - 10:55am.

According to an article from...

Back to page top

According to an article from the Washington Post (excerpt below), a former member of a terrorist organization in the USA is now a tenured professor in Chicago at the University of Illinois. So his kind of free speech is acceptable, but speech about intelligent design is not?

Intelligent design is not a religious belief. It is a theory about how the universe and life came in to existence. Evolution is a theory. Why can't intelligent design be discussed alongside evolution when they both are theories? It was illegal to teach evolution until the Scopes trial. Now it is taught as fact even though it is anything but fact, particularly when it comes to its explanation (if any) of the origin of the first cell.

The public school argument doesn't hold water, particularly on college campuses that are both public and private where suppression of discussion about intelligent design is taking place because intelligent design is not creationism. In other words, it is not quoting from the Bible, it is a scientific theory, just like evolution.

"Former '60s Radical Is Now Considered Mainstream in Chicago

By Peter Slevin
Washington Post Staff Writer
Friday, April 18, 2008; Page A04

CHICAGO, April 17 -- In the 1960s, Bill Ayers and Bernardine Dohrn saw themselves as urban guerrillas who just might be able to overthrow the U.S. government and force an end to the Vietnam War. They were members of the Weather Underground, a radical offshoot of the antiwar movement, who went into hiding for a decade after a bomb accidentally exploded, killing three members of the group."


Submitted by Savage Guy on April 25, 2008 - 2:41pm.

OK, I'll take a deep breathe...

Back to page top

OK, I'll take a deep breathe for you, Savage Guy.
This reminds me of the time my old roommate came home after watching Michael Moore's "Fahrenheit 9/11" for the first time.
You're leaning so far you're about to tip over.
I think it's time for a V8.
I thought the discussion was about freedom of speech in the classroom and I simply pointed out that a teacher can't say whatever they want if it goes against the curriculum.
It's different than freedom of speech, we all enjoy as a result of the First Amendment.
If the University of Chicago hired Ayers to teach about social justice, urban educational reform, narrative and interpretive research, children in trouble with the law, and related issues that's what the college hired him to teach.
It's part of the curriculum.
If that same university hired someone to teach about Intelligent Design, that would be part of the curriculum, and they should teach that theory.
Teachers represent the district, or the college they teach at, not their personal views.
I never said Intelligent Design was religious, although I would argue that most scientists accept the theory as more religious than scientific. That is not to say there aren't scientists who believe the opposite.
If you want to believe a being created life on Earth, that's your business.
If people believe in Creationism, that's fine by me.
If people want to believe in evolution, again, that's fine.
It's open for interpretation, opinion and belief.
To each their own.


Submitted by shawn hogendorf on April 26, 2008 - 1:33pm.

I can't believe you would...

Back to page top

I can't believe you would compare a reaction to "Expelled" to a reaction to "Farenheit 911". You can't get more left wing and sensational to the point of claiming that blatant falsehoods are truths than Michael Moore. You perhaps would say the same thing about Mr. Stein on the other end of the political spectrum.

Whatever the case, intellectual freedom and debate about evolution AND intelligent design is (and has long been) in serious jeopardy in our nations' college science classes because the evolutionists are entrenched and not really interested in giving ground. They know they support a flawed, failed theory, they can't explain how we got the first cell, and their theories about the creation of the first cell include things like aliens planting seeds on earth (!).

Stein is an accomplished actor and raises a serious issue to the forefront of our consciousness. Moore is a left wing hack and a few cards short of a deck. Moore's movies are not taken seriously by anyone except people who lean far to the left because everyone knows about his distortions and lies and that his agenda is overtly political. Stein's movie (hopefully) will get a hearing by all political stripes because it shines a thoughtful light on a serious subject and is not overtly partisan.


Submitted by Savage Guy on April 27, 2008 - 3:08pm.

I apologize for not being...

Back to page top

I apologize for not being clear, I was drawing the same conclusion about Stein on the other side of the political spectrum.


Submitted by shawn hogendorf on April 28, 2008 - 4:36pm.

Here is another article...

Back to page top

Here is another article about Ayers and his relationship with Obama.

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/us_and_americas/us_elections...


Submitted by Savage Guy on April 25, 2008 - 2:46pm.

Here is one of the bodies of...

Back to page top

Here is one of the bodies of work on intelligent design mentioned in the movie.

http://www.discovery.org/a/2177


Submitted by Savage Guy on April 25, 2008 - 3:02pm.

I think I have an...

Back to page top
Keighla Schmidt's picture

I think I have an interesting perspective to contribute.
I went to a private Lutheran school from preschool all the way through my senior year. I was active in church, taught Sunday school and coached sports. I graduated with a 3.3 cumulative GPA, I only mention that to validate my point.
Science classes were taught through religion. Creationism was taught exclusively. I was told the earth is about 2,000 to 3,000 years old. All things began when God said “Let there be light.” From there everything developed.
As a result I went off to college thinking the world is about 2,500 years old and unable to mentally grasp any number any larger than that. I had heard of Darwin and knew, in a very vague, general sense, what he was about. His theories were mentioned in passing and if I recall correctly, we were equipped with bible verses to dispute his theories.
So, when I went to my first semester geology class, I was very ill prepared. Despite being educated in what I’ve since dubbed “selective-Lutheran science” I did not do well in that geology class. I didn’t know how to try to understand billions of years, or how a rock could morph into something another rock form. I got very upset and discouraged and refuse to send my future children to private schools, as a result of what I feel is not a rounded education.
I don’t think either origin should be exclusively taught, but I want my kids to be exposed to the evolution theory, so, perhaps when I’m at home teaching them about the creation theory, they can teach me about the evolution theory. I wish my teachers would have at least taught it to me so that I would be able to understand it. That way, I could feel equipped enough to talk about it and at least know what I was using bible verses to dispel. Now I just shy away from the conversations as I am not confident enough to get into a discussion about it. I have tried to do some research on my own and have found I literally can not get my brain to understand the fundamentals.
I think it will be my duty as a parent to have my children exposed to creation or “Intelligent Design” and let the schools teach about evolution, as I can not.


Submitted by Keighla Schmidt on April 28, 2008 - 10:56am.

It's not...

Back to page top

It's not “selective-Lutheran science” you just had a bad teacher.
There is nothing Lutheran or actually part of evolution that is required to understand forces changing one rock form to another.
A look at the Mount St. Helens shows that most of the changes in form that "require" billions of years can also take place in a few days or hours under extreme conditions.
(other things like the formation of canyons, valley rivers etc... also can be done in days and years, not eaons)

Most of what folks recall as evolution from their science classes is not, it's natural selection or genetics. The part about hard billed birds surviving over soft billed, longer fur on dogs up north. Light colored vs. dark color moths etc... Even the rock moving from one for to another are not evolution.

When you get to College and start taking your first science classes, you will begin to ponder why no one can explain how inorganic stellar matter is able to morph into organic matter. Evolution is not about the belief in small genetic changes in a species, but massive changes from one life form to another.

As one of honors professor at the University said,
remember evolution is not about believing that you are related to Monkeys - that should be easy to prove. But it is about believing you are related to dogs, cats, horses, bumblebees and trees, flowers, rocks.
It is the transformation between species and the transformation of matter to another (stellar, inorganic, organic, single to multi cell) that has always been the problem with evolutionary theory.

So if you went to a school where they didn't teach you that rocks change form under extreme to form other types of rocks, then find a new school. Unfortunately, most of us are paying for schools where they teach us that we all came from rocks.


Submitted by Robert Thibodeaux on April 28, 2008 - 4:39pm.

A bad science teacher? There...

Back to page top
Keighla Schmidt's picture

A bad science teacher? There were many across my 14 years of private education. I don't think you can blame a single teacher, as there were many - which makes me beilieve it's the system they choose to teach.

Choose another school? I was 4 years old to 18 years old, that was all I ever knew, I didn't know that I was missing out on some vital parts of science classes until I was in college. So, having learned that, as mentioned, I am making changes by saying I've learned from my parents and will not be sending my children to private schools, so I am going to "find another school." Furthermore, it was more than just the rocks, that was the one example I used. Again, I can't dispute evolution comments because I know very little about it- that is the point I was trying to make.

Being exposed to both is what really matters. It doesn't take a science teacher to explain creation. "And God said," they get it, it's a parental responsibility. Whereas, a complex science-based theory takes more training to have the capacity to explain it.

In the same way children are exposed to a variety of things such as reading and other languages when they are young to ensure their minds can grow and develop early, I wish the same could have been done in my "science" classes.


Submitted by Keighla Schmidt on April 29, 2008 - 9:44am.

Thanks for your reflections...

Back to page top

Thanks for your reflections Keighla. The concern I have is with the public schools because their teaching is slanted in the far opposite direction of what you experienced at your Lutheran school. They teach evolution as fact even though it is a theory. They don't teach intelligent design (ID) even though it contains truly plausible scientific theory for the origin of the first cell, the species, etc., whereas evolution offers origin of species theories like aliens planting seeds on earth.

ID supporters want secondary and college classroom time to present ID alongside evolution. They both are theories and not facts and both use empirical scientific evidence to make their points. Why not give both theories a chance to prove their point in the classroom?


Submitted by Savage Guy on April 30, 2008 - 12:35pm.

Our Other Sites

Newspapers

The Chaska Herald
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Chaska, Minnesota.
The Chanhassen Villager
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Chanhassen, Minnesota.
The Eden Prairie News
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Eden Prairie, Minnesota.
The Shakopee Valley News
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Shakopee, Minnesota.
The Jordan Independent
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Jordan, Minnesota.
The Prior Lake American
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Prior Lake, Minnesota.
The Savage Pacer
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Savage, Minnesota.
Victoria Town Square.com
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Victoria, Minnesota.
Minnesota Reader.com
Links to news and community information gathered from dozens of Minnesota newspapers, open for comments, discussion and rating by readers.

Entertainment

Let's Go! Southwest
Arts, entertainment and "to do" information for the Minnepolis southwest suburbs includes extensive events calendar.

Churches

Worship Directory
Churches and worship services in the southwest suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul, including the cities of Chaska, Chanhassen, Eden Prairie, Jordan, Savage, Shakopee, and Prior Lake.

Community Guides

Guide to Belle Plaine
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Belle Plaine, Minnesota.
Guide to Carver and Cologne
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Carver and Cologne, Minnesota.
Guide to Chanhassen
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Chanhassen, Minnesota.
Guide to Chaska
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Chaska, Minnesota.
Guide to Eden Prairie
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Eden Prairie, Minnesota.
Guide to Excelsior
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Excelsior, Minnesota.
Guide to Jordan
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Jordan, Minnesota.
Guide to Prior Lake
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Prior Lake, Minnesota.
Guide to Savage
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Savage, Minnesota.
Guide to Shakopee
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Shakopee, Minnesota.
Guide to Victoria
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Victoria, Minnesota.

Classifieds

Southwest Jobs Now
Job listings and career opportunities in the southwest suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul, including the cities of Chaska, Chanhassen, Eden Prairie, Jordan, Savage, Shakopee, and Prior Lake.
Southwest Homes Now
Real estate listings and homes for sale in the southwest suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul, including the cities of Chaska, Chanhassen, Eden Prairie, Jordan, Savage, Shakopee, and Prior Lake.
Southwest Shop Now
Job listings, used items, garage sales, and everything you'd find in the classifieds. Items from the southwest suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul, including the cities of Chaska, Chanhassen, Eden Prairie, Jordan, Savage, Shakopee, and Prior Lake.
Motorbuys.com
Shop online for a great selection of vehicles from Central Minnesota and the Southwest Metro Area.

Coupons

SaverFreak, Minnesota's once-a-week super coupon deal.
Southwest Coupons Online
Printable coupons for deals and discounts from stores and service shops in the southwest suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul, including the cities of Chaska, Chanhassen, Eden Prairie, Jordan, Savage, Shakopee, and Prior Lake.

Special Directories

Welcome Home
Home improvement, remodeling and real estate construction tips and services in the southwest suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul, including the cities of Chaska, Chanhassen, Eden Prairie, Jordan, Savage, Shakopee, and Prior Lake.